There seems to be some criticism on some sectors of the alt-right, or if not the alt-right per se, individuals that are to the right of cucks, about White nationalism on the basis that there is no White nation or identity.
The main argument, they claim, is that historically there has been no such thing as "White culture" or "White identity". There is, they say, "German culture", "Irish culture", etc. Whites have never been a single bloc and have gladly killed and enslaved each other for centuries.
I will show that such arguments are not only wrong—worse, they're irrelevant.
Atomistic Fallacies
So first of all, if you're so eager to say that there's no White identity/culture/nation because what actually exists is German, Irish, Scottish etc. culture then I have to ask you what makes you think that there are such cultures too? The South of Germany is deeply Catholic, while the North is Protestant, and the two have very different cultures. The people in the Scottish Lowlands are very different from those of the Highlands, southern Italians are basically Third Worlders to the northerners, and don't even get me started with those fucking Catalonians in Spain.
So why is it that you're OK with saying there's a German culture and people when, clearly, there's no such thing? There are only Bavarians, Ostfrieslanders, people from the Han Stadts, etc. We could further divide this and say that the people from West Bavaria are not the same as East Bavarians. Or that there are some very different villages inside West Bavaria and that it's not accurate to use West Bavaria as an umbrella term to include them. Just keep going until you reach the point where there are only individuals and society is not real.
Common Threads to all Whites ...
Posts
